Participation and Technical Expertise in Brazilian Regulatory Agencies: Should Regulation be Submitted to the Will of the Majority?

Authors

  • Raianne Liberal Coutinho Brazilian Health Regulatory Agency image/svg+xml

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26512/2446-52592018e19126

Keywords:

social participation, public consultation, Brazilian Regulatory Agencies, regulatory decision-making, administrative process theory

Abstract

Purpose ”“ The purpose of this study is to analyze social participation in Regulatory Agencies in contrast to their technical expertise, in order to expose some challenges related to the participation of society in decision making processes

Methodology/approach/design ”“ Two cases were analyzed, where the evidence-based regulation of the Agencies was in opposition to the participation of society: the case of the public consultation of the re-evaluation of the Carbofuran pesticide and the public consultation of the bill authorizing the commercialization of the substance phosphoethanolamine.

Findings ”“ Participation and technical experience of the agencies are reconcilable, as long as some issues are observed, such as the adoption of non-binding mechanisms that stimulate the discussion.

Practical implications ”“ It is hoped that this article will help Regulatory Agencies to adopt participatory mechanisms appropriate to the proposed discussions, as well as to analyze the contributions received, reinforcing the institutional legitimacy.

Author Biography

  • Raianne Liberal Coutinho, Brazilian Health Regulatory Agency

    Advogada. Técnica em Regulação e Vigilância Sanitária na Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária (Anvisa) desde 2014. Membro do Grupo de Pesquisa Observatório de Políticas Públicas (GEOPP).

Published

2018-05-15

How to Cite

COUTINHO, R. L. Participation and Technical Expertise in Brazilian Regulatory Agencies: Should Regulation be Submitted to the Will of the Majority? Journal of Law and Regulation, v. 4, n. 1, p. 1–20, 15 May2018.